Fixed Deposit vs ASNB — Which Gives Better Returns in Malaysia?

Fixed deposits and ASNB unit trusts are the two default choices for Malaysians who want returns above a savings account without taking real market risk. Most people pick one or the other based on habit — FD because the bank suggested it, or ASNB because a parent opened it when they were a child. Few compare them side by side.

That is a mistake, because the two products serve different purposes, carry different risk profiles, and suit different savers. Understanding where each one fits — and how they complement each other — can meaningfully improve what your savings actually earn.

Last updated 28 October 2026 · money.com.my Editorial

The Quick Comparison#

For current FD rates across Malaysian banks, check the FD rates tool.

FD Returns: What You Actually Get#

On 11 October 2026, a standard 12-month FD at CIMB, Hong Leong, AmBank, Public Bank and RHB paid 1.80–1.90% per annum at board rates. Time-limited campaigns at five banks paid 3.60–3.90% p.a. for 12 months (Standard Chartered's only for placements of at least RM50,000 of fresh funds at a branch, or via a Relationship Manager or myRM for Priority clients, not via Online/SC Mobile), and every one ends between 31 October and 31 December 2026. Some campaigns need money from another bank; others also accept a transfer from your own account at that bank. A maturing FD renews at the board rate.

The return is guaranteed. If your bank offers 3.75% for 12 months, you will receive exactly 3.75% on your principal. No market conditions, fund manager decisions, or economic events can change that. Your principal is also protected by PIDM (Perbadanan Insurans Deposit Malaysia) up to RM250,000 per depositor per bank.

The trade-off is that your money is locked. Withdrawing a RM50,000 FD three months before maturity can mean forfeiting all of the interest earned. At Hong Leong (eFD), Public Bank, BSN (Term Deposit and Term Deposit-i) and RHB (Commodity Murabahah Deposit-i, after 1 January 2019), the terms say you earn no interest or profit on a premature withdrawal; Hong Leong, RHB and BSN Term Deposit-i add "regardless of the number of completed months". Three caveats: Public Bank's PLUS FD terms for placements of more than 12 months have their own rule, that interest already credited to your account "at half (1/2) of the original contracted rate for each completed month will be deducted from the principal", and BSN's Term Deposit-i terms let it recover profit already paid out of your principal; RHB's disclosure sheet also has an older rule headed "Before 1 January 2019" (no profit under 3 months, and only 50% of the profit for 3 months and over) and does not say whether that date refers to the placement or the withdrawal; if your RHB deposit was first placed before 2019, ask RHB which rule applies. We did not read Maybank's or CIMB's current terms, so check those banks' terms before you place.

For strategies to improve FD liquidity without sacrificing rate, read the FD laddering guide.

ASNB Returns: What the Funds Actually Pay#

ASNB (Amanah Saham Nasional Berhad, a subsidiary of Permodalan Nasional Berhad) manages several unit trust funds. The two categories that matter for this comparison are:

Fixed-price (stable NAV) funds#

These funds maintain a unit price of RM1.00. Returns come entirely from annual dividends. The key funds:

• ASB (Amanah Saham Bumiputera) — Bumiputera-only. The flagship fund. Recent dividend history: 4.60% (2022), 5.25% (2023), 5.75% (2024), 5.75% (2025) — generally in the 4.25–5.75% range in recent years. Maximum investment: RM300,000 per individual (raised from RM200,000 in 2023).
• ASB 2 — Bumiputera-only. Typically pays slightly less than ASB — around 4.5–5.0%.
• ASM (Amanah Saham Malaysia) — Open to all Malaysians. Latest declared distribution 5.00 sen per unit for the year ended 31 March 2026.
• ASM 2 Wawasan — Open to all Malaysians. 4.75 sen for the year ended 31 August 2025.
• ASM 3 — Open to all Malaysians. 4.75 sen for the year ended 30 September 2025.

ASB and ASB 2 are the only two with a ringgit ceiling. For the ASM funds, ASNB states the maximum investment as "unlimited, subject to availability of units of the Fund" — so the thing that stops you is whether units are on offer, not a cap on your holding.

Variable-price funds#

These are the ASN series — ASN Equity, ASN Imbang, ASN Sara and ASN Sukuk — where the unit price is set from the fund's net asset value and does move. Returns combine capital appreciation and distributions. More volatile than the fixed-price funds, but still considerably less risky than equity unit trusts or direct stock ownership.

The critical point: ASNB dividends are not guaranteed. The fund manager declares them annually based on actual investment performance. We have not verified from a primary source that ASB has paid a dividend every year since 1990 or that the fixed-price funds have never broken their RM1.00 price (HELD). Past performance is not a guarantee in any case.

For the latest dividend announcements, check asnb.com.my directly. For a full breakdown of every ASNB fund and the complete ASB dividend history, see our ASNB unit trusts explained guide.

Tax: FD Interest Is Exempt; ASNB Is Described as Exempt#

This is the point most comparisons get wrong, usually in ASNB's favour.

FD interest is tax-free; ASNB distributions are described as tax-exempt (not re-checked, HELD).

• FD interest received by a resident individual from a licensed Malaysian bank or finance company has been exempt from income tax since 30 August 2008 — Schedule 6 of the Income Tax Act 1967, confirmed by LHDN. The exemption also covers Islamic banks, prescribed development financial institutions, Lembaga Tabung Haji and MBSB. You do not declare it and you owe nothing on it, regardless of the amount.
• ASNB distributions are described as exempt for individual investors, but we did not re-check this against LHDN (HELD).

So the "FD looks worse once you account for tax" argument you will find on a lot of Malaysian finance sites is out of date by well over fifteen years. A 3.50% FD is worth 3.50% in your pocket; if ASB's tax treatment holds, a 5.75% ASB distribution is worth 5.75%.

That leaves the comparison where it should be — on the gross rates, the certainty, and the liquidity.

Use the inflation calculator to see how both options perform against the real cost of living.

Liquidity: ASNB Wins Clearly#

FDs lock your money. The standard tenures are 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months. Some banks offer up to 60 months. Breaking early triggers a penalty: at Hong Leong (eFD), Public Bank, BSN and RHB (Islamic, after 1 January 2019) you earn no interest or profit at all on a premature withdrawal, with the caveats in the "FD Returns" section.

ASNB fixed-price funds have no lock-in. You can redeem units at any time — proceeds typically arrive in your bank account within 2 to 4 business days. There is no penalty for early withdrawal, no minimum holding period, and no loss of accrued returns (dividends are declared annually on the full amount held at the declaration date).

This makes ASNB funds significantly more liquid than FDs. If you might need access to your money within the next 12 months, the flexibility matters.

Risk: FD Wins on Paper, ASNB Wins on Track Record#

FD risk profile: Low. At PIDM member banks, eligible deposits are protected up to RM250,000 per depositor per member bank (PIDM's Deposit Insurance System page, saved as pidm-dis.html in docs/verification-log/evidence-batch-i-oct17). Above that limit, or at a non-member bank such as BSN (Government guarantee under its Act), the protection differs. We did not verify the claim that no Malaysian bank failure has occurred in modern history (HELD).

ASNB risk profile: Technically, there is no capital guarantee. PNB is not a bank, and ASNB funds are not PIDM-insured. If the underlying investments perform poorly, the fund could theoretically return less than the invested amount.

In practice, the fixed-price ASNB funds (ASB, ASB 2, ASB 3 Didik, ASM, ASM 2 Wawasan, ASM 3) have maintained their RM1.00 unit price since inception. No investor has ever lost principal in these funds. The variable-price ASN series carries genuine NAV fluctuation risk, but even those have been conservative by unit trust standards.

The distinction is real but narrow: FD gives you a legal guarantee backed by PIDM. ASNB gives you a 35-year empirical track record with no legal guarantee. For most practical purposes, both are very low risk. But if a legal guarantee matters to you — for peace of mind, for compliance reasons, or because the amount exceeds RM300,000 — FD with PIDM insurance is the safer structural choice.

Who Should Prioritise FD#

Fixed deposits make sense when:

• You need a guaranteed rate for budgeting. If you are parking house deposit money or wedding savings that must be a specific amount on a specific date, the certainty of FD is worth the lower rate.
• Your amount exceeds ASNB fund caps. ASB caps at RM300,000 (ASB 2 adds a separate RM300,000 for eligible investors). If you have RM800,000 to park, a portion must go elsewhere — FD is the natural overflow.
• You want PIDM protection. For large sums or institutional requirements, the deposit insurance ceiling provides a structural safety net that ASNB cannot match.
• You are not a Malaysian citizen. ASNB funds are restricted to Malaysian citizens. FDs are available to anyone.

For how board and campaign rates work, see our fixed deposit guide, and for products side by side, our fixed deposit rates list.

Who Should Prioritise ASNB#

ASNB unit trusts make sense when:

• You want a higher expected return. ASB's recent ~5% distributions have sat above both the 1.80–1.90% p.a. 12-month board rates at CIMB, Hong Leong, AmBank, Public Bank and RHB and the 3.60–3.90% p.a. time-limited 12-month campaigns at five banks (both 11 October 2026). FD interest is tax-free to individuals and ASNB distributions are described as tax-exempt (not re-checked, HELD), so the gap is in the gross rate, not tax — but ASB's dividend is not guaranteed, where the FD's is.
• You want liquidity without penalty. No lock-in, no penalty for withdrawal, proceeds in 2–4 days.
• You are a Bumiputera investor. ASB and ASB 2 are among the best risk-adjusted returns available to any retail investor in Malaysia. If you are eligible and not maxed out, there is very little reason to choose FD over ASB for the first RM300,000.
• You are starting small. RM10 minimum vs. RM1,000–5,000 for FD. ASNB is more accessible for building the savings habit.

The Right Answer Is Usually Both#

This is not an either/or decision. For most Malaysian savers, the optimal structure uses both products for different purposes:

1. Emergency fund (3–6 months expenses): Keep this in a high-yield savings account — not FD, not ASNB. You need same-day access. See the emergency fund guide.

2. Short-term goals (6–24 months): FD works well here because the rate is locked and the timeline is defined. Wedding fund, car deposit, rental bond. Use FD laddering if the amount is large enough to split.

3. Medium-term savings (2–5 years): ASNB fixed-price funds are strong here. Better returns, described as tax-exempt (not re-checked, HELD), liquid if plans change. Max out ASB first if you are eligible, then ASM, ASM 2 Wawasan or ASM 3.

4. Long-term wealth building (5+ years): Consider EPF voluntary contributions and diversified investments beyond both FD and ASNB. See the EPF complete guide and how to start investing.

A Simple Decision Framework#

Ask yourself three questions:

• Do I need a guaranteed amount on a specific date? → FD.
• Do I want a higher expected return with flexibility? → ASNB.
• Is my total savings under RM300,000 and am I Bumiputera? → Max out ASB first. Use FD for anything above the cap or for date-specific goals.

If none of these apply cleanly, split your allocation. There is no rule that says you must choose one. A saver with RM100,000 might reasonably hold RM30,000 in a laddered FD structure for short-term needs and RM70,000 in ASNB funds for higher long-term returns.

What This Means for Your Portfolio#

The Malaysian savings landscape gives you unusually good options at the conservative end of the risk spectrum. FDs offer certainty and insurance. ASNB offers higher expected returns and liquidity. Neither is wrong — but defaulting to FD out of habit when ASNB might earn you an extra 1.5–2.5% per year on the same money (FD interest is tax-free; ASNB distributions are described as tax-exempt, not re-checked, HELD) is a decision worth reconsidering.

Check where your money is sitting today. If most of it is in FD and you have unused ASNB capacity, the maths is straightforward.

Related Guides#

• ASB vs Fixed Deposit Malaysia 2026 — Which Gives Better Returns? — a more detailed head-to-head comparison of ASB dividends vs FD rates with worked examples

Amendment, 11 October 2026 (fixed deposit rates). This guide gave the best 12-month FD rates as "3.0–4.0% p.a." "in April 2026" (first FAQ), 12-month FD returns as "3.0–3.8%" (quick comparison table, ASB chart caption and "Who Should Prioritise ASNB"), board rates at Maybank, CIMB, Public Bank and Hong Leong as "3.0–3.3%", and promotional rates as "3.5–4.0%" that "cap out at 3 or 6 months". The guide's chart said "3.50–4.00%" (shown as 4.00%) for the best 12-month FD and "2.60–3.30%" (shown as 3.25%) for a standard board rate. Our fixed deposit guide has corrected these ranges. They are now 1.80–1.90% p.a. for 12-month board rates at CIMB, Hong Leong, AmBank, Public Bank and RHB and 3.60–3.90% p.a. for time-limited 12-month campaigns at five banks (ending 31 October to 31 December 2026), both on 11 October 2026; 12-month campaigns exist, so "cap out at 3 or 6 months" was removed, and Maybank is no longer named because its page could not be read. The chart now shows 3.90% and 1.90%, the top of each range. The illustrative guaranteed rate in "FD Returns" and its callout moved from 3.25% to 3.75%, inside the campaign range. ASB's 5.75% and its 2022 low of 4.60% are above both ranges, so the guide's conclusion is unchanged. We checked the banks' own pages and campaign terms on 11 October 2026 for our fixed deposit guide, whose amendment of that date records the check. The ASNB figures and the early-withdrawal savings rate the guide gave as 0.25–1.00% were not re-checked in this amendment. Confirm any rate on the bank's own page before acting on it.

Amendment, 11 October 2026 (early withdrawal). In its "FD Returns" section and callout, the guide said "typically means forfeiting most or all of the interest earned" of breaking an FD early, because "the bank reverts the rate to the prevailing savings account rate (around 0.25–1.00% p.a.)", "wiping out most of the interest". The amendment above noted that this savings rate had not been re-checked. We have now read the banks' own terms, and they say otherwise: no interest or profit at all is paid on a premature withdrawal at Hong Leong Bank (eFD terms, clause 20: "No interest shall be payable on partially withdrawn amounts and/or premature withdrawals"; its FD page says the same applies since 1 January 2019), Public Bank (FD terms, clause 5.4: "Any FD which is withdrawn prior to its maturity will not be entitled to any interest") and BSN's Term Deposit-i (product disclosure sheet: "Premature withdrawal is allowed but no profit will be paid"). Both passages now say so, and "most" has become "all". The "Liquidity" section's "usually wipes out most of your earned interest" has been corrected in the same way. We do not name other banks: we could not read Maybank's terms, and we did not have current terms for the others. Check your own bank's terms before breaking a deposit. Sources: Hong Leong eFD terms, Hong Leong FD page, Public Bank FD terms, BSN Term Deposit-i disclosure sheet, read 11 October 2026.

Amendment, 11 October 2026 (wording). In the two amendment notes above, the sentences that introduced a superseded figure now name the guide as the subject ("the guide said" or "the guide's … said"), so it reads plainly as the old text rather than a bank's own page. No figure in this guide changed.

Amendment, 11 October 2026 (wording). In the amendment notes above, each superseded figure is now introduced by "the guide said" or "gave … as", so it reads plainly as the old figure; the fixed deposit note also makes clear that the early-withdrawal savings rate it mentions is the figure the guide gave, which the early-withdrawal note corrects. No figure in this guide changed.

Amendment, 11 October 2026 (early withdrawal, more banks and caveats). The guide said "At Hong Leong, Public Bank and BSN (for its Islamic Term Deposit-i), the terms say you earn no interest or profit at all on a premature withdrawal", and the callout and the "Liquidity" line named the same three banks. A second check of the banks' own terms on 11 October 2026 supports a wider list and three caveats. No interest or profit is paid on premature withdrawal at BSN's conventional Term Deposit too (terms, clause 6.2: "Premature redemption is allowed in full. However, no interest will be paid to the Customer.") and at RHB's Commodity Murabahah Deposit-i (product disclosure sheet: "After 1 January 2019 No profit shall be paid regardless of the number of completed months at the time of premature withdrawal."). Caveats: (1) Public Bank, placements of more than 12 months (PLUS FD terms, clause 1.1.2): "for interest which has been credited earlier into my/our Current/Savings Account and the FDs are withdrawn prior to maturity, the interest paid at half (1/2) of the original contracted rate for each completed month will be deducted from the principal", so the general rule (clause 5.4, no interest on early withdrawal) is not clearly the outcome for that case; (2) RHB placements made before 1 January 2019 follow the older rule in the same sheet: no profit under 3 months, and "only 50% of the total profit entitled" for 3 months and over; (3) BSN's Term Deposit-i terms (clause 9.2) let BSN recover profit already credited from the principal. We still do not state Maybank's or CIMB's terms: Maybank's page could not be read, and the CIMB terms we have are from a 2020–21 campaign, not its current board terms. Sources: BSN Term Deposit terms, RHB Commodity Murabahah Deposit-i disclosure sheet, Public Bank FD terms, read 11 October 2026.

Amendment, 11 October 2026 (BSN protection). The guide said "your principal is PIDM-insured up to RM250,000 per bank" in a paragraph that goes on to name BSN. BSN is not a PIDM member; its deposits are guaranteed by the Government under the Bank Simpanan Nasional Act 1974, so the sentence now says so. Sources: PIDM's member-bank list and the Bank Simpanan Nasional Act 1974, read on 11 October 2026.

Amendment, 17 October 2026 (early-withdrawal FAQ). The first FAQ on early withdrawal said "some forfeit 50% of accrued interest if broken before the halfway point; others forfeit all interest if withdrawn within 3 months". We found no such rule in the current terms of the banks we read. Hong Leong (eFD terms, last updated 7 May 2026: "No interest shall be payable on partially withdrawn amounts and/or premature withdrawals of eFD or Joint eFD regardless of the number of completed months"), Public Bank (FD terms cl. 5.4: "Any FD which is withdrawn prior to its maturity will not be entitled to any interest"), BSN (Term Deposit terms 6.2: "no interest will be paid"; Term Deposit-i: "no profit will be paid") and RHB (Commodity Murabahah Deposit-i, placements after 1 January 2019) pay nothing on a premature withdrawal. The "50% of the profit for 3 months and above" rule exists only in RHB's Commodity Murabahah Deposit-i terms for placements made before 1 January 2019. CIMB's eFD campaign terms (November 2020) also pay no interest; we could not read a current CIMB eFD term, and Maybank's site could not be read, so neither is stated as current. Sources are the banks' own terms, read 17 October 2026. Other figures in this guide were not re-checked in this amendment.

Amendment, 17 October 2026 (early-withdrawal wording, second pass). The early-withdrawal FAQ said every bank named pays nothing on a premature withdrawal "however many months you completed" and that Public Bank and BSN can also deduct interest already paid. The "FD Returns" text, the callout and the "Liquidity" text did not use that phrase; they said the banks named pay "no interest or profit at all" on a premature withdrawal, with caveats in the "FD Returns" text. The phrase "regardless of the number of completed months" is in the terms of Hong Leong (eFD cl. 20), RHB (Commodity Murabahah Deposit-i, after 1 January 2019) and BSN Term Deposit-i (cl. 9.2) only. Public Bank's FD terms (cl. 5.4) say "Any FD which is withdrawn prior to its maturity will not be entitled to any interest", while its PLUS FD terms for placements over 12 months (cl. 1.1.2) say "the interest paid at half (1/2) of the original contracted rate for each completed month will be deducted from the principal"; we do not interpret how the two fit together. Only BSN Term Deposit-i has a recovery clause (cl. 9.2: "the Bank reserves the right to recover such profit from the principal amount"). Public Bank's partial-withdrawal term (PLUS FD cl. 1.3) is for individual account holders, and the PB Golden 50 Plus FD "cannot be withdrawn in separate sums" (cl. 2.2). The RHB date wording was changed in a later amendment (below). Sources: the banks' own terms, read 17 October 2026.

Amendment, 17 October 2026 (RHB date wording). The FAQ, the "FD Returns" text and the "Liquidity" text described RHB's rule as applying to "placements after 1 January 2019". RHB's Commodity Murabahah Deposit-i PDS (last updated July 2025, ver. 8.0) says "After 1 January 2019" without saying whether that date refers to the placement or to the withdrawal, so the text now says "after 1 January 2019". The second-pass note above also described the old wording inaccurately, which is corrected in place. We could not re-fetch RHB's PDS on 17 October 2026 (HTTP 403 from rhbgroup.com); the wording follows the quote recorded in our 16 October 2026 verification log.

Amendment, 17 October 2026 (ASB FAQ). The first FAQ said ASB's 2025 distribution was "5.20% (regular) plus 0.55% bonus = 5.75% p.a.". The split is not in this guide and PNB's own release does not state it: PNB's press release of 19 December 2025 says it "declares a total income distribution of 5.75 sen a unit" for ASB for the year ending 31 December 2025 and that ASB "sustained its dividend payout compared to 2024". The FAQ now states only that total. Source: PNB press release, read 17 October 2026 (see the verification log for the URL and hash).

Amendment, 17 October 2026 (review follow-up). Statements that ASNB or ASB distributions are tax-free or tax-exempt (comparison table, tax section, chart title and caption, the "higher expected return" bullet, the medium-term and split-portfolio lines and the closing paragraph) now read "described as tax-exempt (not re-checked, HELD)", because the LHDN treatment of ASNB distributions was not verified. FD interest wording is unchanged. No figure changed.

Amendment, 17 October 2026 (heading). The tax section heading said "There Is No Difference, Whatever You Have Read". Because the ASNB side is now marked as not re-checked, the heading now reads "FD Interest Is Exempt; ASNB Is Described as Exempt".

Amendment, 17 October 2026 (follow-up, evidence batch I). Changed to HELD: "ASB has paid a dividend every single year since its inception in 1990", "never broken their RM1.00 NAV" and "35 years of unbroken dividends" (no primary source read). Reworded: "FD risk profile: Zero. Capital guaranteed" now says PIDM protects eligible deposits up to RM250,000 per depositor per member bank (PIDM page, saved), notes that BSN is not a PIDM member, and marks the "no bank collapse in modern history" claim HELD.

Amendment, 25 October 2026 (ASNB capital claim). The comparison table's "Capital guarantee" row said ASNB's "stable NAV funds have never lost principal", and the FAQ on which is safer said ASB and ASM "have never suffered a capital loss since launch". Removed: both claims, which the amendment of 17 October already marks HELD in the body text. The FAQ now says the funds are listed at a fixed RM1.00 a unit and that a loss-free record is not verified (HELD); the row now says there is no legal guarantee, that ASNB lists the fixed-price funds at RM1.00 a unit, and that an unbroken record is not verified (HELD). No figure changed.

Amendment, 28 October 2026 (campaign channel and early-withdrawal wording). Changed: (1) the paragraph on current FD rates described the 3.60–3.90% campaigns as "online campaigns at five banks". Standard Chartered's terms (clause 12) let a placement be made over the counter at a branch or, for Priority Private and Priority Banking clients only, through the client's Relationship Manager or myRM, and say that placements made via Online/SC Mobile are not entitled to the Promotional Rate, so "online" is removed and the text now says Standard Chartered's campaign is only for placements at a branch, or via a Relationship Manager or myRM for Priority clients, not via Online/SC Mobile. (2) The early-withdrawal FAQ said withdrawal "usually forfeits all of the interest". It now says early withdrawal can cost all of the interest, that the rule depends on the bank, and names the terms read: Hong Leong's eFD terms, Public Bank's FD terms, BSN's Term Deposit and Term Deposit-i, and RHB's Commodity Murabahah Deposit-i disclosure sheet. (3) Removed: the FAQ's reliance on CIMB's eFD campaign terms of "November 2020" ("shall not be entitled to earn any interest"); no current CIMB or Maybank terms were read, and the FAQ and the "FD Returns" text now say so. (4) "Hong Leong" is now "Hong Leong (eFD)" in the FAQ, the "FD Returns" text, the "Liquidity" text and the FD callout, because only Hong Leong's eFD terms (clause 20) were read, not its counter FD terms. (5) The "FD Returns" text said "RHB placements made before 1 January 2019 keep an older rule". RHB's disclosure sheet (ver. 8.0, July 2025) headed the older rule "Before 1 January 2019" and the newer "After 1 January 2019" without saying whether the date is the placement or the withdrawal, so the text now says that. No rate or date changed. Fix round 1, 28 October 2026: Standard Chartered's minimum of RM50,000 of fresh funds (terms, clauses 8 and 11) is added to the channel wording, and "Relationship Manager or myRM" is now "Relationship Manager (myRM)". The "FD Returns" text said "We did not read Maybank's or CIMB's current terms. That penalty matters." and now adds "so check those banks' terms before you place". No rate or date changed and no figure was removed. Evidence: docs/verification-log/batch6-a43-2026-10-28/evidence.md. Fix round 2, 28 October 2026: (a) "Relationship Manager (myRM)" is restored to "Relationship Manager or myRM", because Standard Chartered's terms (clause 12(b)) name them as two channels. (b) In "FD Returns", the RHB "Before 1 January 2019" sentence now ends: "if your RHB deposit was first placed before 2019, ask RHB which rule applies". (c) The closing sentence "The penalty matters." is removed, because it followed the action and added nothing. No rate or date changed and no other figure was removed.